• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Dr. Buzby's ToeGrips for Dogs

Help for your slipping dog

  • What Are ToeGrips?
  • Dr. Buzby’s Blog
    • Vet Blog Team
  • SHOP NOW
  • Show Search
Hide Search
SHOP NOW

Dog Euthanasia: Knowing When to Say Goodbye

Julie Buzby DVM, CAVCA, CVA May 22, 2019 85 Comments

Share
Tweet
Pin62
62 Shares
dog euthanasia photo of rainbow and title saying goodbye to your dog

Are you struggling to know when to say goodbye to your dog? Most likely, your canine companion has been by your side through the joys and sorrows of life. He or she has been steadfast in their loyalty and love. You’ve walked life’s path together—both literally and figuratively. Making the decision to let your grey-muzzled companion go may seem unbearable. Dog euthanasia is not an easy topic to broach, but comfort, hope, and help are here.

In part three of my series on dog euthanasia, I’m joined by my friend and veterinary colleague Dr. Elizabeth Chosa, owner of Courtenay Animal Hospital. Dr. Chosa shares a heartfelt message on selflessness as a final “gift” to our dogs during end-of-life care. If you are conflicted in knowing when it’s time to say goodbye to your dog, I hope you find peace and comfort through Dr. Chosa’s story of a 15-year-old dog named Rosie.

For parts one and two in this series on dog euthanasia, please read:

  • Saying Goodbye to Our Dog: Dr. Buzby’s Heartfelt Story
  • How Will You Know When It’s Time to Euthanize Your Dog? 5 Caring Thoughts for Peace & Comfort

If you’d rather listen, please check out my podcast on dog euthanasia: Thinking Through the Goodbye.

Saying Goodbye to Rosie

by Dr. Elizabeth Chosa

photo of senior dog
A tribute to senior dog, Rosie.
Photo credit: Dr. Elizabeth Chosa

A week ago today, we said goodbye to a special patient, a dog named Rosie. She was 15 years old and had been rescued from a local shelter by her mama a long time ago.

Every day from that day until she said goodbye, Rosie’s mama did every single thing she could to ensure that Rosie was as healthy, happy, and as comfortable as possible. Life for Rosie was as good as it gets. And, as companions go, her mama also felt like she had won the lottery.

This is all any of us can hope for when it comes to pet ownership—to have a beloved animal who becomes like a part of you and lives a good long life, where each of you makes things better for the other.

But when you are lucky enough to have such a relationship with an old pet, it means you’ll also eventually have the burdensome responsibility of deciding when to say goodbye to your dog.

Talking openly about dog euthanasia

Rosie’s mama and I had a long talk last week and I asked her if she wouldn’t mind sharing parts of it with you. Some people don’t know what questions to ask and aren’t able to openly talk about the process as easily as Rosie’s mama did. I thought sharing some of our talk may help others as they approach this heart-wrenching decision. It (dog euthanasia) can be a very difficult conversation but it’s such an important one.

Pretty much everyone hopes that their senior pet will one day pass peacefully in his or her sleep. Choosing a time and day to end the life of a beloved companion feels unnatural. It can be an incredibly difficult task and one that is often fraught with inevitable guilt for those who love their pets.

photo of golden dog's face and quote about dog's life being too short

Alleviating suffering: the last gift of love

Unfortunately, pets rarely pass peacefully in their sleep, at least not before enduring an enormous amount of suffering, in most cases. Giving them the gift of alleviating that suffering is the last loving, generous act of pet ownership.

Thinking through the goodbye

But how do you know when it is time? One of the hardest factors is that animals often have good days and bad days near the end. On the bad days, especially after several in a row, owners often think it is time to let go. Sometimes they even make an appointment, only to wake up that morning and find their pet having a great day, which makes them doubt the decision and hold off a bit longer.

This cycle may repeat for weeks or even months and owners are unsure where their responsibility lies. No one wants to give up too soon, nor do they want to wait too long.

photo of old dog looking out window and title dog euthansia: thinking through the goodbye

Passing peacefully

The reality is that if you really love your pet and you have thought “it might be time”—it is almost always time. It’s just so hard to face that reality. I have had to make the decision for my own senior pets twice in the past two years and it never gets easier.

But it’s important to keep in mind that it is a loving gift for them, to go peacefully when they are surrounded by people who love them, and not alone and scared or in tremendous pain and distress.

Tools to help you know when it is time to say goodbye to your dog

One simple tool that can help is to write on a calendar “good day” or “bad day” then look back over the last 10-14 days. If the bad days are outweighing the good ones, it’s time to let your pet go before all of the days are bad.

Another idea is to make a list of your pet’s very favorite things to do. When he or she stops doing those two or three things, it is time to say goodbye. Decide in advance that you won’t waver and it will make the decision more objective.

Your dog has given you their very best throughout life and they deserve to leave with their dignity intact, while they can still stand up on their own and they are not incontinent. If you wait until they have completely stopped eating, cannot rise on their own, or are lying in their own waste, you have waited too long.

After more than 20 years working in the veterinary profession, I have talked to countless people who say that looking back they wish they hadn’t waited so long. But I have never had a single loving pet owner come back and say they regret letting them go too soon.

Again, if you’ve thought that it might be time, it probably is time.

Your veterinarian can help you through the decision process

If you are approaching this decision (dog euthanasia), your veterinarian would be happy to help you through the process and give as much insight as possible into how your pet might be feeling. As veterinarians, our job is to advocate for the animals, but we also want to help family members come to a decision that will provide the most peace of mind possible during the difficult moments.

  • Sometimes that means making a housecall so that pets can pass comfortably in their own homes.
  • Sometimes it means sending home additional medications for hospice care to keep our patients comfortable until other family members can say goodbye.
  • Sometimes it means an owner will sing a song to the pet or take pictures or select a unique memento to honor the final moments.
  • Everyone grieves differently and there is no judgment from us—only education and compassion.

A consultation with Rosie’s mom

When Rosie and her mom came in last week, it was just for a consultation. There was no rushing the process or the timeline. As we talked, she began to realize that the time should perhaps be sooner than she expected—for Rosie’s sake.

three photos of senior dog
Rosie was having more bad days than good days.
Photo credit: Dr. Elizabeth Chosa

I took the pictures above of Rosie before her mom left to take her to the car. Rosie’s mom and I talked about scheduling an appointment for the following week.

And then a few minutes later, Rosie’s mom came back inside. She had decided to let Rosie go the very same day. We gave Rosie a sedative first and she fell asleep right next to her mama; she was snoring quietly when it was time…and she didn’t have to feel anything at all when the final moment came.

If only we could all pass so peacefully and with such dignity.

About the author

Dr. Elizabeth Chosa is the owner of Courtenay Animal Hospital in Merritt Island, Florida. She is my friend, colleague, and inspiration in the way that she cares for her veterinary clients and her patients. Dr. Chosa graciously allowed me to share this story so that others who are considering dog euthanasia and knowing when to say goodbye to a canine companion may benefit from a real-life situation. I hope you find comfort and peace in your decision. For more about Dr. Chosa’s practice, please visit the Courtenay Animal Hospital website or Facebook page.

Filed Under: Senior Dog Care

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Emma says

    August 15, 2026 at 11:36 pm

    hi I’m struggling I have 8 dogs two on Palative care both are gsd
    one is 13.5 Zeus has DM and awful arthritis bone in bone in his hips I hear them cracking as he walks. he’s knuckled over too on his hind feet and worn his claws down. to nothing but no bleeding or soreness I’ve noticed today he has an elbow pressure sore he’s chewed at . he eats and gets excited about his meals. . he still tries to run into the garden but his hind legs can’t carry him. he sleeps a lot now and goes into deep sleeps where it is hard to wake him . at night he pants and whimpers just laying there staring into space. his spirit is still Zeus but his body is fading fast now . he was on the librealla injections but I stopped them as she started to act disorientated and got bad black poo after the 6th one . he’s just on metacam now. I can see he’s in pain and lost at times but he’s a brave gsd that is head of his pack of 8 dogs so isn’t letting his guard down even though I can see he’s growing weaker and weaker now. I just can’t feel the same as I have with letting my other 3 dogs go in the past. everyone says I’ll know when it’s time I did for them but for Zeus I just don’t know. he’s had a couple of accidents in the house over a month nothing awful. but that’s stressed him out he’s a proud clean dog I feel he’s only living to do his job and that’s lead the rest of the pack. . I just don’t know if it’s time. end of life evaluation only 6 questions were ok out of 20 .
    then there is my other gsd. he’s working lines head strong with a greedy for attention and to learn things he’s hyper active and yobby he challenges Zeus but they are both as bad as each other and Zeus will always have the upper hand Jet just loves to intimidate him . it’s what they have always done never have fights just jet being vocal in his face and Zeus shouts back and just walks past him .
    jet is 9 he has lumberbascal disease. diagnosed two years ago. vet agreed with me he wasn’t a dog suitable for any kind of operation. he had to sedate him to just do an examination. .
    jets a tough dog hard dog with so much energy he would even give a Mali a run for their money.
    jets now at the stage I can see him. in pain . I was told his more nuro than pain . but those last few months he’s got more aggregated. his balance is more off and looses his back end some days and struggles to get his hind legs upright after laying down. he’s not a dog you can help as he will become snappy . he’s his own boss .. mentally he’s got worse his more hyper and his legs can’t cope with his mind. he’s loud and vocal like Zeus is still and he enjoys his food. he loves attention still and is always at the door when you walk in but I can see he’s in a lot of pain I’m sure he is he chews his front legs hard and has opened them up in places making them bleed and I feel this is frustration from pain , he did have a go at librealla but he went absolutely crazy on it. it affected him badly more hyper and vocal and just totally out of control . he’s having metacam but again when the pain is managed he’s off his head running himself off his brain. he’s so full of life but is this because he’s in pain. and frustrated being I high driven dog is he reacting to pain differently to some dogs it’s so hard. they are both my babies but I have a deep gut feeling I need to let them go. but it’s so so hard . both doing totally different things . jet has also got more affectionate and needy lately too very needy. not like him . he can’t get on the sofa and struggles now with the stairs I’ve tired stopping him using them as he comes down dragging his rear end often. but his brain and front legs are still that of a pup. it’s so hard. he’s not a dog you can contain he will go mental he’s mentally got worse everyone tells me this and I know deep down my boy has but he’s not senile or slow. but going the other way because he’s such a high driven working lines dog. , sadly he’s always suffered behind front a pup so I was never able to work him like he would have loved. I’ve never had such a brave bold driven dog like him he’s big for the faint hearted but he’s such a lovable yobbo. I just don’t know what to do. even sedating him will be a struggle. . but his rear end is bad he’s got no power there and his tail is limp . pleas help me am I right in considering allowing him to pass with Zeus when he’s still mentally hyper and loving life but is this due to him experiencei.ng pain as he is a super anxious dog too he will be 9 in November .he came to be at 6 months as he was hard for his owner manage . I won’t lie Jet is hard work, has been from day one but I’ve always loved his greed to want to learn as I had to teach him mental stimulation due to his lameness all his life. he knows some good tricks and still loves to do them I have his brother from another mother same dad but Bob his brother is totally different the biggest of all but the most last laid back dog I’ve ever met he’s my shadow . Zeus and jet are similar but both on a different scale of Palative care. . it’s so difficult , I wanted to get a quality of life evaluation from my vet. he’s straight talking and will give me his advice ias if the dogs were his and I know exactly what he will say and that would be that it’s time when I’m ready , , but Iim struggling , . thank you.

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      August 24, 2026 at 8:53 am

      Dear Emma,
      My heart aches for you as you face this difficult decision for two of your beloved dogs. I know how hard it is to choose to say goodbye and it is perfectly normal to have very conflicted feelings. I do think it is ok to let go before all joy is lost and the only thing that remains is pain. I would rather say goodbye one day too early than one day too late and allow unnecessary suffering. We allow our own hearts to break in order to give them peace. I will attach links to other articles with more information and great advice from other readers as well. Hoping you can find the advice you need to navigate this emotional path. Praying for strength and comfort. Bless you, Zeus, and Jet. ♥

      1. Using a Quality of Life Scale for Dogs
      2. How Will You Know When It’s Time to Euthanize Your Dog? 5 Caring, Heartfelt Messages
      3. Degenerative Myelopathy in Dogs: Stages, Symptoms, Care
      4. When to Euthanize a Dog With Arthritis: A Vet’s Heartfelt Advice
      5. Preparing for Your Dog’s Euthanasia: 10 Thoughts for Peace

      Reply
  2. Traci Martin says

    August 15, 2026 at 2:19 pm

    I have a 14 year old schnoodle he’s amazing he was diagnosed a few years ago with diabetes liver disease thyroid disease he takes 2 units of insulin twice a day and thyrosyn and Denamerin ursidol daily twice a day on everything but the denamarin it’s one pill one hr before breakfast he eats a special food he’s been we’ll taken care of with his meds he has always taken his heartworm meds no heart worms checked yearly. He’s been completely and totally loved every minute of his life. He has a break or damage in his back hip but we caught it before it got to bad that steroids and muscle relaxers helped dr said most animals don’t get brought in until it’s to late to save them so I’m so thankful for this bit over the last two weeks. Last week during the night he started acting wrestles and wouldn’t stop going I say all over sounded like he started falling so I finally got up and went to him and he was on his side all legs just like he was riding a bicycle I got him up and held him wrapped him in a blanket to control and comfort him he finally stopped that but he was really like just kicking and stuff I thought ok he’s in pain so I got him a muscle relaxers and gave him a little piece of a pain pill and a steroid he finally calmed down but he couldn’t stand so I held him for hours and then he was finally ok enough to lay down I was totally confused. Then last night I heard him and immediately went to check on him and when I bent down to get him he kinda fell over and started breathing hard and his legs started like bicycling so I got my husband up and told him I believe these are seizures and he came out of it but couldn’t stand up on his own so I wrapped him up and held him for a few hours I slept holding him and then he woke up seemed to be fine and thirsty and he could stand on his own. I’m so confused of this is the time me and my husband need to talk about this question. He’s been an amazing doggie I don’t want him to be in pain or suffer but I’m stuck between a rock and a hard place in making that scary decision what’s your opinion on what I’ve mentioned here ? Thanks Traci M

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      October 5, 2026 at 4:44 pm

      Dear Traci,
      I am sorry your boy is experiencing these worrisome seizure episodes. I strongly encourage you to reach out to your vet and see if they think he needs to be brought in for an exam. It may be that these seizures are due to a worsening of his diabetes or liver disease. Your vet would be able to tell you if there is a way to improve your dog’s situation or if saying goodbye is the most loving option. Hoping you can get the answers you need to make the best decision moving forward. Praying for comfort and peace for your sweet pup.

      Reply
  3. Jamie says

    July 14, 2026 at 10:35 am

    I know there is never a “perfect time” and you never want to wait too long and let your pet suffer in any way but wanted to write in with a gentle reminder that you don’t want to do it too soon either. In many cases, it is SO very hard to know. Every situation is unique. I thought I was doing the right thing for my terminal dog and giving her a gift but believe now that the decision was made in part due to a time of extreme stress because of her long illness and burnout from caregiving. Since I made that decision I have been living with not only the grief of losing my best friend but the guilt that I did it too soon. A decision like this is one of the most difficult we will ever make and we always want to do the very best for our pets. I believe now what might have helped in my case was some help in her caretaking. Not only would it have helped me get a break physically but also emotionally. If you think these things might be affecting your decision, ask a friend for help, or if you have the resources, pay someone to assist you. That’s what money is for and it may make all the difference. It’s at least worth trying and could have possibly given me a few more days with my beloved dog and perhaps more peace. Prayers for all going through this.

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      September 28, 2026 at 3:26 pm

      Dear Jamie,
      You are correct that caregiver fatigue can be a deciding factor in whether owners choose to say goodbye or not. I am sorry you experienced it in such a big way. Thank you for sharing your story with us. Praying for healing and comfort for your heart. ♥

      When Caring For A Sick Pet Becomes Too Much: Pet Caregiver Fatigue

      Reply
  4. Amanda Damone says

    October 21, 2025 at 3:50 pm

    We put our dog Jack down last week. He was fifteen and three months and medium-to-large, about 60 lbs. We thought he had arthritis but it didn’t respond to coseqyn, gabapentin, and carprofen. I now think he had a neurological issue like a lumbar degeneration because the vet noted a positive conscious proprioception test in the rear legs. He was falling, had ataxic gait, would cry out in pain at times when trying to get up or when being picked up. He panted a lot like he was in pain. He would circle and then finally collapse into a lying down position and then lick his side. He hasn’t sat on his butt in years. Most recently he had fecal incontinence once a day for ten days out of his last thirteen days. We had been using a sling or carrying him up and down stairs to get to the yard for over a year. He also had some cataracts in both eyes but I don’t know how severe. I worry that we should have tried physical therapy or acupuncture or gotten an MRI to confirm the diagnosis. He was still eating but he mostly needed to be lying down to eat and it took a while for him to finish a meal. Do you think it was time?

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      October 22, 2025 at 9:50 am

      Dear Amanda,
      I understand your conflicted emotions about the loss of your beloved Jack. It is normal to ponder the “what ifs” while grieving, but please don’t let guilt have any part of this. You made a loving choice to offer him peace and freedom from his struggles. I would have done the same for one of my own. I do think you chose the best path to spare Jack from unnecessary suffering and am certain he knew how much he was loved. May the memories of all the good times you shared stay with you always. Bless you as you continue life’s journey. ♥

      Reply
  5. D&S says

    August 12, 2025 at 8:39 am

    Disappointed in the fact that I tried to post something here, reach out for some little words of guidance or support, anything… and my post was filed under “senior dog care” and no response. This is also what i’m facing at ER’s and Dog hospitals – staff deems what is “treatment” to what fits their description even though a dog is in the stages of heart failure, I guess the same way as support is here.

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      August 13, 2025 at 10:56 am

      Hi D&S,
      I am sorry you are struggling with feelings of a lack of support and empathy from the veterinary community. I assure you that your post was not filed away and that it was safely waiting for me to read it. We receive hundreds of comments each month and it can take some time to give each one the individual attention it deserves. I hope you will see my reply to your other message as well as this one. Praying for peace and comfort for your sweet boy.

      Reply
  6. D&S says

    August 9, 2025 at 8:23 am

    My dog just turned 6 and is currently in heart failure. He was born with CHD and has been on meds since then. He was doing well until suddenly 2 wks ago he started coughing and gagging so much and that’s when his decline began. He still has such an energetic spirit – I see his fight to want to live which makes me sad and guilty. He loves his sweet potatoes and toys but I’m seeing signs that he’s slowly changing. Grunts when he changes his positions because of the pressure near his heart, regular trembling from the meds,… he recently had an episode while I was holding him (not sure if it was syncope or a seizure) and it terrified me. He made this loud wail, his body went stiff and then flopped in my arms and then in 20 seconds he woke back up and was playing like nothing had happened. I am scared that I will be/am ignoring signs of his pain and will make a mistake when deciding what to do. Lots of guilt and sadness…

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      August 13, 2025 at 10:50 am

      Dear D&S,
      My heart aches for you as you face this difficult situation with your beloved boy. From what you describe, I do think he may be nearing his last days. I am not sure if there are any medications or treatments that could make him more comfortable. It is hard to offer specific recommendations without playing a personal role in your pup’s medical care. It may be helpful to contact a local vet that specializes in hospice/in home services. They can walk this emotional path with you and give guidance along the way. I do think that it is better to say goodbye one day too early than one day too late and allow unnecessary suffering. I will attach links to other articles with more information and great comments from other readers as well. Praying for clarity and strength as you continue to care for your sweet boy. Bless you both. ♥

      1. Signs of a Dog Dying of Heart Failure
      2. Using a Quality of Life Scale for Dogs
      3. How Will You Know When It’s Time to Euthanize Your Dog? 5 Caring, Heartfelt Messages
      4. Dog Hospice Care Can Bring Peace and Dignity to Your Dog’s Final Days

      Reply
  7. Angela Martin says

    July 31, 2025 at 1:47 am

    Hi,
    I have found reading all this information really helpful. My lovely Lotti is a 14yr old Lab and I’ve had her since birth. She has Laryngeal Paralysis. Apart from difficulties with her larynx she is fit, enjoys walks, food etc Sometimes when swallowing food, saliva or water she gags, chokes and vomits. It sounds terrible and can be so stressful. This may happen once/week. She also coughs and clears her throat alot. She’s definitely not running around as much as she used to but that is also age. My vet feels that it would be kinder for me to let her go now rather than risk a choking incident or aspirational pneumonia. I am feeling that I need to make a decision on a ‘what if’ basis. But what if that was never to happen and she could’ve enjoyed another 6mths of life? I feel like I’m in a terrible dilemma between losing her now unnecessarily or risk losing her in a most horrid way. I am keeping good/bad days on my calendar and I hope you can help me.

    Reply
    • Julie Buzby DVM says

      September 12, 2025 at 10:15 am

      Dear Angela,
      I understand your concern for Lotti and can see why you are conflicted about how to proceed. I am proud of your vet for bringing up the topic of euthanasia. Often times we hesitate to have this discussion and then it is mentioned way too late in the progression of disease. With that being said, while euthanasia may be an acceptable choice, it doesn’t mean it’s the right fit for everyone in this situation. As long as your girl is not suffering and is still enjoying life, it is ok to give her more time. As long as you are aware of the risks and are making an informed decision, the decision is still yours to make. You have to trust your intuition as you know your girl better than anyone. Praying for clarity and strength as you navigate this difficult path. Wishing you and your sweet girl all the best.

      Reply
« Older Comments

We welcome your comments and questions about senior dog care.

However, if you need medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment, please contact your local veterinarian.

Cancel reply

We welcome your comments and questions about senior dog care.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

NEW From Dr. Buzby


NEW! Introducing Dr. Buzby’s Brain Boost™ organic MCT oil for senior dogs. Discover a boost of natural energy for a healthier brain and a happier dog.

BUY BRAIN BOOST™

OUR BEST SELLER

Shop Now

BEST SELLER! Dr. Buzby’s ToeGrips®—instant traction for senior and special needs dogs who struggle to walk on slippery floors. Help your senior dog enjoy more good days.

BUY TOEGRIPS®

About Dr. Buzby

Dr. Buzby with a golden retrieverDr. Julie Buzby has been an integrative veterinarian for twenty years and has earned certification by the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association in 1998, and by the International Veterinary Acupuncture Society in 2002.
READ MORE

Looking For Something?

Featured Blog Posts

Dog Leg Anatomy (& Common Conditions by Location)

How to Help a Dog Lose Weight: 13 Tips From a Veterinarian

Is MCT Oil the Same as Fish Oil for Dogs? No, Here’s Why

MORE BLOG POSTS

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Podcast

The Buzby Dog Podcast

LISTEN

Important Note

Dr. Buzby’s Blog offers tips on how to give your dog the happiest life possible. The content is presented solely for informational purposes and may not be relied upon to replace face-to-face medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment by professional pet healthcare providers. [more]

Get Your Free Senior Dog Health Guide!

Be the first to know about the latest senior dog health care tips from Dr. Buzby, exclusive savings, & early access to new offers.

Plus get your free ultimate dog health guide.

Unsubscribe At Any Time

Get Your Free Senior Dog Health Guide!

Be the first to know about the latest senior dog health care tips from Dr. Buzby, exclusive savings, & early access to new offers.

Plus get your free ultimate dog health guide.

Unsubscribe At Any Time
Silhouette of a girl holding a yellow umbrella over a dog while sitting on a bench and title Dr. Buzby's and phrase Helping people. Helping dogs.
  • ToeGrips FAQ
  • Brain Boost™ FAQ
  • Instructions
  • Retailers
  • Wholesale
  • Guarantee
  • Reviews
  • About
  • Vet Blog Team
  • Affiliate Program
ToeGrips_USA

NEED HELP? Contact Us!
[email protected]
Text: (843) 781-6430

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Privacy Policy   |   Return Policy   |   Shipping Terms   | Terms of Service
© 2026 Dr. Buzbys ToeGrips. All Rights Reserved.