
Finding peace in your heart after the goodbye
Grieving the loss of a dog after euthanasia is every shade of difficult. After listening to a dear friend express the guilt she felt following her dog’s euthanasia, integrative veterinarian Dr. Julie Buzby shares a heartfelt message on finding peace after the goodbye.
I learned something this week that broke my heart. My friend Jamie has been living with needless guilt for years over the way her dog was euthanized.
Having been a part of hundreds of dog euthanasias, I’m melted each time by the grief, but I’ve also come to terms with the value of a peaceful, gentle euthanasia. However, it never occurred to me that a client might linger in doubt or guilt about the way their pet was euthanized.
So I think it’s worth having a hard conversation about grieving the loss of a dog after euthanasia. After Jamie and I talked, she sent me the sweetest message:
“Thank you for the kind words. It puts peace in my heart.“
Whether saying goodbye to your dog is a part of your past or your future, I want you to have peace in your heart too.

Two senior dogs and two different goodbyes
So let’s back up to beginning. In the midst of a recent string of texts Jamie and I exchanged about senior dog care, she asked me this question about dog euthanasia:
I had two different experiences with saying goodbye to my two dogs. And I keep questioning which one was right?”
This clearly wasn’t a conversation to be had via text. So I called her and asked for the backstory before I offered my thoughts.
Here is Jamie’s story about grieving the loss of her dogs:
Saying goodbye to Sabrina: Jamie’s story
“When I lost my first dog, Sabrina, it was winter. My parents were snowbirds and living in south Florida. I had planned on driving to stay the holiday with them as Sabrina and I always had.

It turned out to be the longest trip of my life as I stopped at various veterinary hospitals along the way since Sabrina was not breathing well. I finally made it to my destination and for a few days Sabrina perked up. But when we had two nights in a row without sleep due to her labored breathing, no longer wanting to eat nor even sit in the room with our family, I knew it was time.
Related article: Signs Your Dog is Dying
The next morning, I went to a local veterinary office while Sabrina stayed home with my parents. The vet came out and spoke with me, read Sabrina’s records that I’d brought along, and we scheduled her appointment for later that same day.
When the vet met Sabrina, he said she was so calm that only one shot would be needed. He explained that once he gave the injection, it would take no longer than 10 seconds to work.
I looked into Sabrina’s beautiful brown eyes and told her that I loved her and everything I wanted to say. My mom and sister-in-law were at my side also telling her how loved she was. Within what felt like two to three seconds, she dropped into my arms. The vet then listened for a heartbeat and softly told me she was gone. I held her for ten minutes and then my father and brother came in and helped me to the car.
Ruminating over the guilt of my dog’s passing
It was not until years later that I would feel guilt about my decisions and the questions I did not ask.
When I knew my next dog, Rémedy, only had a little time left, I was blessed to be able to take almost two weeks off work to be with her. Rémedy was a blind/deaf dog I had rescued.
Related article: Meet Rémedy—10 Tips for Whole Pet Healthcare
I always sensed Rémedy felt so alive at the ocean. She would put her head up in the breeze and sniff the oceans smells. She even had an extra pep in her step when we would walk along with our feet/paws in the ocean.

So we traveled to Folly Beach. We also went to our favorite spot at the river. We spent time with family. And of course I spoiled her with her favorite treats.

Making arrangements for Rémedy’s goodbye
I had made arrangements with my local vet to say goodbye in a specific way. I told the vet I wanted Rémedy to be on my lap, and I wanted to hold her the whole time. We went in to the room—my mom was at my side. The room was lit softly, and the vet came in and told me there would be two shots. One to relax her and then the final injection. I said ok. But once the first injection was given, her head dropped and she was completely out of it. Not relaxed…gone.
Before the euthanasia injection, the vet asked me, “Are you ready?” Then a second time, “Are you sure you are ready?” even though I had answered yes the first time. I held my girl and told her how I loved her. Then the vet listened for a heartbeat and told me she was gone. I held her for ten minutes and then my parents helped me leave.
I left that experience with a lot of guilt and sadness. The first shot did not just relax her. She was limp.
Grieving the loss of my sweet dog after euthanasia
If I had known she would be that out of it, I would have said the things I wanted to say to her before that first injection. Or maybe I would have requested just one shot, like Sabrina. Or I would have said my last words to her first and then told the vet to immediately give the second shot and not ask me and wait in between.
I’ve often replayed it in my mind.
Since then, I have discussed my experiences with others who are making the difficult decision for their dogs. I’m still left not knowing what is right and what is wrong so that I may be prepared better for the next time.
I do know I should have asked many more questions. For example, does one method cause pain while the other is painless? I don’t know why this question didn’t come to me at the time, but who is thinking clearly when they are about to lose their best friend?”
Dr. Buzby shares a heartfelt message of comfort
As I listened to Jamie share the differences between Rémedy’s and Sabrina’s passing, my heart ached for her. It was clear that her unanswered questions had lingered and guilt had bubbled up over the years causing her unnecessary pain.
However, I also knew that words of reassurance, comfort, and truth could help. Here’s what Jamie needed to know:
There is no “right” way to perform a euthanasia in terms of standard operating procedure. Ultimately, euthanasia is about what is best for the dog. Period.

And after that, it’s about determining the preferences of the dog’s family. Like most of veterinary medicine, helping a dog transition out of this life is more of an art than a science. This is precisely why Jamie had two different experiences, and why she was conflicted.
The guiding principle for end-of-life care
While there is no “right” protocol for dog euthanasia, there is a “right” guiding principle. The “right” way to perform a euthanasia is to make it physically and emotionally pain free for the dog. Dog euthanasia is euphemistically referred to as “putting a dog to sleep” for a reason. That’s the goal.
Sabrina’s vet opted to give her one injection because he believed that, in her debilitated state, she would go right to sleep without any struggle from the euthanasia solution, which essentially induces general anesthesia and then gradually stops the heart.
With Rémedy, the vet opted to “take out an insurance policy” to guarantee a perfect process. Dog euthanasia has to earn a procedural perfect 10 every single time. There is no room for error.
By administering a sedation injection in advance, this vet followed the protocol that the vast majority of vets use today. I almost always administer a sedative injection before the final injection for these reasons:
- any anxiety or pain the dog is feeling melts away under the influence of the medicine
- when the dog relaxes, the owners also tend to visibly relax
- and, if I’m honest, the vet is more relaxed too because a quiet, calm goodbye is almost guaranteed once the dog is sedated.
Facilitating a compassionate goodbye
A euthanasia appointment is such a precious, vulnerable time for the hearts of all present. I’ve obliged all kinds of special requests because there is no “right way.”
My final answer to the question Jamie texted me is this: both vets were right. They both facilitated a compassionate, peaceful goodbye.
Honoring your dog by giving yourself peace
If the guilt of your dog’s goodbye lingers in your heart—whether your dog’s passing was recent or years ago—I hope that by sharing Jamie’s story, you find peace. Ultimately, you were there for your dog in those final moments when he needed you most.
If you’re preparing for your dog’s passing
If your dog’s passing is looming on the horizon, please read part two of this series: Preparing for Your Dog’s Euthanasia: 10 Thoughts for Peace. We’re here to offer comfort and support during this difficult time.
Finally, if you’re navigating your dear old dog’s senior years, I invite you to sign up for my weekly updates, tips, and articles dedicated to senior dog care.


I recently made the heartbreaking decision to put our 12 year old Australian Shepherd Dakota to sleep. He had a inoperable liver tumor which had sores to his entitling by the time we discovered it. He had good days and bad days towards the end but he always tried his best to show affection no matter how much pain he was in. We made the decision to put him to sleep to relieve his pain. The decision still haunts me as I can’t get past the grief of holding him in my arms as he was given the injection. I feel as though I let him down in some way, that he trusted me to keep him safe and I did just the opposite in the end. I know in my heart of hearts that it was the best thing for him. and I can only hope he felt how much I loved him in the end.
Dear A Brock,
I am sorry you had to say goodbye to your sweet boy. I understand what a difficult decision it is and how it leaves us heartbroken. I am glad you were able to be there with Dakota to the very last second. I have no doubt he knew how much he was loved. Making the decision to let go is the final act of tremendous love we can show to our faithful companions. You allowed Dakota to have his final peace and rest and I pray his memory will continue to be a blessing.
I appreciate this post, but I am struggling with heart shattering guilt. Our almost 14 year old lab mix, Marley, was diagnosed with cancer 5 months ago. A tumor on the throat that the vet said was inoperable. We soaked up every last minute together, but at the end he was struggling to eat, his breathing was fast and shallow, and he just laid in bed 23 hours a day. BUT he still wanted his walk (albeit slowly and painfully, while stumbling) up until the end. And when we finally thought it was time, he wagged his tail when I said “ride” to go to the vet. It broke my heart. I almost called it off. Now I’m afraid we put him down too soon? Was that little bit of spark worth the pain? Also, our vet’s office is so busy now with staff shortages, the process felt rushed and I’m torturing myself with the idea that he was stressed and confused for his last moments. I don’t know if I can forgive myself. And how effective is the sedation? How do we know that they don’t feel any pain? Thank you for any insights you have. I knew this would be hard, but I had no idea. The pain and guilt feels physically painful.
Dear Christen,
I am so sorry that your final moments with Marley were rushed and left you hurting. I definitely think you made the right decision to say goodbye. It sounds like Marley was suffering but, in true lab fashion, still found joy in spending time with you. Making this decision leaves us with grief, but it is the most loving and caring thing we can do for our senior dogs. You allowed Marley to find peace and rest and took his pain away. The sedation is extremely effective and affects the brain within seconds, giving pain relief taking away anxiety. I am glad you were able to be there with Marley until the very end. I am positive he knew how much he was loved. I hope with time you will let this guilt fade away as it is not your burden to carry. May his memory be a blessing to you and your family.
Last week wile I was walking my 11 year old fur baby (Luna), a neighbors pitbull attacked her. Biting her abdomen, with Lunas efforts to fight back her jaw dislocated. It was a image I will never forget. I was screaming frantically, in panic, upset and so heartbroken. Seeing her alive but hurt, I put her in a towel she was bleeding and put her in the car. . I rushed to the nearest Vet I could find it was a 40 min drive but it felt like the longest day in my life. The vet expressed after seeing her status that i should consider putting her down. But I was willing to do anything to keep her alive. He gave me some options but ultimately because of her age it was going to be a difficult healing process. Luna was a rescue from Puerto Rico. I brought her to Florida. Now I feel very empty, She was my everything. I have no kids. She was my baby.
Dear Jennifer,
I am so sorry to hear of this horrible experience for you and Luna. The decision to say goodbye is never easy, but I feel with your vets help, you made the right decision. For many of us, dogs are our closest family and dearest friend, but I hope with time your empty feeling will ease. May you find comfort in the many wonderful memories you shared together over the years. She was a lucky girl to have been rescued by you. So sorry again for your loss.
It’s been over five years now since I lost my childhood best friend. We had to euthanize him after he rapidly declined over the span of three days due to internal bleeding caused by a tumor in his gastrointestinal tract. At the time I was only 16 and I didn’t let myself grieve properly. After just 6 months, I convinced my dad to get a new dog, thinking it would fix the situation. But, this created tension between me and my siblings because my decision affected their grief process. They hated our new dog for a few years and I felt guilty that this new dog was being resented by people in his new home and for disregarding my siblings’ grief. After realizing the gravity of the decision (while taking the new dog for a walk), I broke down crying realizing that by bringing in a new dog to my life, I would lose him one day. Things are better between us now as siblings and they adore him now. I finally allowed myself to grieve his loss 4 years later until I got a message from him in a dream that he made it to the other side and that he’s alright. But now, our new dog (whose become incredibly attached to me) is reaching into his geriatric years and the death anxiety I feel is getting worse (even though he’s happy and healthy). I’m paranoid that one day he too will die suddenly and I won’t be able to cope with the loss. I’m doing my best to make the most of our time together while he’s still here but it’s like at the same time I’m worried about getting too attached to him which will make that dreadful day even more unbearable. I’ve talked about my feelings with family and have tried to look up more resources about death so I can come to accept my dog’s mortality and feel at peace. But I still find it hard to let go of this anticipating grief (even though everything is fine). What should I do?
Hi Lee,
What a difficult situation. I’m so sorry for the loss of your childhood best friend and the grief and turmoil of the past few years. I am glad that things have gotten better between you, your siblings, and your new dog. I understand how difficult it is to love a dog and know that you will lose them at some point. No matter how long you have with them, it never really seems like enough time. I think that making the most of your time with your dog and trying to think through/talk through your feelings are both great steps. There are a variety of resources (books, brochures, support groups, hotlines, etc) that can be helpful when processing the loss of a dog. One such list of resources can be found on the OSU Veterinary Medical Center’s Honoring The Bond program website (. Thanks for reaching out about this and sharing your struggles that I suspect many other dog parents understand quite well. ❤
We just had to put our almost 14 year old Bichon to sleep. Zeus was the most sweetest and loyal friend!! Having to decide to put him to sleep was the hardest decision to make. He became so sick so quick and I could not bare to see him suffer another day. I have had an incredible empty feeling for losing him along with a lot of guilt thinking I could have done something different to help him earlier. It was so hard to come home to our house afterwards. Everything reminds me of him. and I miss him so much!
Hi Cindy,
I am so sorry for the loss of your Bichon. It is always so difficult to lose a beloved dog and to be reminded of him everywhere you look. I hope that in time you will be able to let go of the guilt you are feeling. I understand how easy it is to second guess your decisions but in the end that just makes you carry an unnecessary and harmful burden. I have no doubt that Zeus knew how much you loved him and that you made the decisions along the way that you thought were best at the time. Sending love and comfort as you go through the grieving process. ❤
I’m struggling with guilt and the what if’s from his sudden loss.
He had just turned 10 and was a German Shepard. He went from 100% normal one night to lethargic and then collapsing the next day. He had a pericardial effusion and pericardiocentisis and the effusion returned after just 14 hours the morning after his overnight stay. They recommended euthanasia and suspected a hermangiosacroma tumor on his heart. The other option was the heart tap again, but it would probably just return.
The logical side of me thinks that if the first heart tap didn’t work, why would the second? but the what if’s haunt me. What if I brought him in 6 hours earlier when he was unusually lethargic, but before he collapsed? What if i did the heart tap again? Would the outcome have been different or did his heart just decide to start bleeding that day and that was his fate no matter what? Hard to accept when I had a happy healthy dog one day and he was gone the next.
Hi Charles,
I am so sorry for your loss. It is so difficult to see your dog be normal one day and gone the next and to wonder if things could have been different. It sounds like you (and the veterinary team) did everything right for him, so I hope in time you are able to find peace with the decisions you made. There are so many times in life that we can get consumed with the “what ifs” but we just can’t change the past. All we can do is make decisions with the information we have in front of us at the time.
Unfortunately, bleeding into the pericardial sac often presents exactly the way it did for your dog, and very rarely has a good outcome. With those cases, there usually isn’t any way you would have known there was a hemangiosarcoma growing on his heart until it started bleeding like it did. He had a ticking time-bomb in his chest and most likely, nothing you could have done would have changed that. One of my friends and fellow vets was a guest author for me, and wrote about losing her dog to splenic hemangiosarcoma (same tumor but on the spleen). I think reading it might be helpful in your healing process. It is called Hemangiosarcoma in Dogs: Symptoms, Treatment, and Life Expectancy. So sorry again for your loss. ❤
I lost my previous Molly 2 days ago. The guilt is just so overwhelming. She was admitted for suspected pyometra. By the second day her tummy was swollen double the size, they had to put her on oxygen cause she was struggling to breath. She wasn’t responding to the medication. I’m not even sure if I was present when they gave the second shot. My heart aches
Hi Marianne,
I’m so sorry for the loss of your dear Molly. Losing a beloved pet is always so difficult. I hope that in time the guilt lessens and you are able to find comfort and peace. ❤
We put our husky Koda, to sleep yesterday?. It has been one of the most difficult decisions of my life. Koda, was just shy of 16 years old, my sons girlfriend ran over him in the driveway about 7-8 years ago, he was under her tire and she didn’t see him. He survived it, but as he got older he struggled with arthritis, in his hips. Then dementia started to set in. He was struggling with walking, laying down, and paced the floor until all hours of the night until finally settling down at 3 to 5 am. He couldn’t walk up stairs without rolling down, so I would help him up and down the stairs, he slept by me just outside my bedroom door, and he refused to change that habit, so I helped him, to protect him from more injury. Then going out to relieve himself became a problem, trying to balance and falling in his mess was hard to watch. At times he was in so much pain he couldn’t find a way to lie down, so he would just fall over, hitting his head on whatever was close. He was constantly falling and could not get up alone. Watching Koda struggle was so difficult.. I made the decision to put him to sleep because of the constant pain, the inability to walk normally, and have a quality life and he had lost 10 lbs.. Putting him to sleep was painless for him. The sedative the doctor gave him worked and the final shot took seconds. But now I can’t stop crying, I am filled with overwhelming grief, and guilt, like I did something wrong. Should I have gave it more time, should I have gave him stronger medicine, he was already on daily pain pills and joint medication. The thought of taking a life has just overwhelmed me.. I can’t seem to even function. I did it because he was struggling and at his age, it wouldn’t get better. I was afraid to leave him, he seemed lost and confused at times, and I was thankful with Covid, because, I have been here with him constantly for 10 months. Please tell me I did the right thing?. I lost my son, a few years ago, and this is just snowballing, I have to find some peace and understanding in all this. We do what we think is best for them, so they don’t suffer, but then we suffer for making the decision to end their life ?
Oh Colleen, my heart hurts for you. Losing the ones we love is so devastating. Please hear me when I say that you absolutely did the right thing for Koda. You gave him a wonderful life with you and then at the right time, you gave him the gift of a painless death. As veterinarians, we understand well the gravity of ending a life, but also the sweetness of knowing a beloved pet is no longer in pain. I urge you to release yourself from any guilt you feel. It is clear from your post that you cared for Koda so much and were dedicated to ensuring he could live his best life with you for as long as possible and to giving him a dignified end. I hope you are able to find peace in time. You have my deepest sympathies for the loss of your son as well.
Colleen,
Thanks so very much for sharing your experience and story with your baby, Koda. While reading your story, I felt like you were writing on my behalf. I, too, had to put my almost 16 year old Golden Retriever, Cassie, down 3 days ago. We adopted Cassie from a rescue organization when she was about 9 months old. She had already had a litter or puppies and her evil owner dumped her and her puppies on the side of the highway. I kind person picked her up with her babies. She was sick with heartworms, very thin, and balding when we brought her home. She was the perfect family pet in every way.
Cassie was deteriorating in so many ways. She struggled to walk as her hind legs were getting weak and her right side even weaken which caused her to fall toward the right. She slipped and slid all over our hardwoods and it was pitiful to see her try to stand or walk. She managed okay on carpet areas which she preferred. She also needed help when going out to potty as she was unstable on most days and I worried she would fall into her own poo. I purchased a “help em up” knock off harness about a year prior which was a God send with helping her with stairs and/or general support. She had been on vet prescribed pain meds (carprofen) for several years which definitely kept her pain at bay. Her eyes were so glossed over with cataracts as most old dogs develop. She paced quite a bit and mostly near feeding time. She became intolerant of dog food at age 14, so she was on a homemade diet of Instant Pot turkey, peas, sweet potatoes, scrambled eggs, turkey bacon. She licked her front feet and legs obsessively and I’ve now learned that’s an indication of their attempt to relieve pain. We almost lost her in 2019 when we thought she had a stroke, but it was thankfully vestibular disease. She recovered after a few months.. We had many more months with her.
As far as the decision to put her down, I kept waiting for “that sign” as if she would tell me one day when she was ready. Every day I wondered if she would still be with us. I knew the day was near though. She never sent that signal that it was time and she likely never would. Last Saturday morning, Cassie had left her normal poo poo surprises in her room. No big deal as she just couldn’t always go through the night. However, a few hours later I noticed her struggling to stand to her feet because she was pooing while laying down. She was visibly bothered by her inability to stand at such a time. I just knew she was very near, so scheduled via the online Emergency Vet and proceeded forward.
My guilt and grief seems also very overwhelming. How could I take a life? Cassie trusted me and I drove her and walked her into her death. I had every opportunity to back out. Like you, maybe I could have increased her meds or done something more. I struggle terribly with the thought that I took a life…of my sweetest girl of 16 years. I’m trying to recognize that her life was really good with us. Cassie went on almost 50 camping trips all over the Southeast. She was never boarded and always traveled along with us. She loved the beach and the mountain hiking trails. She loved her younger companion, Petey, as well. She taught my son how to walk 11 years ago as she let him grab her back fur for support and she strolled him around the house. She was terrified of thunderstorms and always found her way to our bed to quiver for hours. She was a gentle soul and is greatly missed. I’m trying to find peace with her passing. It was so very peaceful as she just fell asleep. I know if there was “that sign” one day, then that could have been very painful for her and/or traumatic for everyone. I hope I saved her that agony that many elderly dogs experience. Rest in peace sweet Cassie girl. You brought so much joy to our family. Thanks to all who have shared their stories here as it has helped me through this grieving process.
Dear Stephanie,
Thank you for sharing your story. Cassie was so lucky to have had you in her life. You went above and beyond for your girl. Please don’t carry around the burden of guilt for your decision. Letting go of a beloved dog is heartbreaking for us, but is the most loving and selfless decision we can make. You allowed Cassie to find her final rest and peace. I have no doubt she knew how much you loved her. I hope her memory will continue to be a blessing and bring you comfort.
We lost our pet puggle of 17 years after a few days with seizures.. She started with me finding her going down in a corner. I was not sure what that was about. Next day she had her first short duration seizure and two more after that 24 hours apart. All of short duration. She had been diagnosed with idiopathic seizures so I thought these of short duration issues were related. As a result of these issues she would randomly fall down. Sometimes got stuck in corners and also so anxious when we left her which did not happen very much. The last issues were attributed to doggie dementia. Had been going on for years. I was really worried after the third one seizure. I called my vet first thing Saturday morning because I wanted her to be seen. They downplayed the seizures and asked if I wanted an appointment on Monday. Which I did make. Could not see her that day. Shortly after that she had another short duration seizure followed be a few more over a few hours. The last of 5 minutes so I called the emergency vet 45 minute drive away. I packed her up and she had another long duration seizure in my truck which actually knocked her out. They treated her on Saturday but seemed to focus on putting her down. She was totally knocked out almost 5 hours later. I left her for the night hopeful she would improve. There was no improvement the next day. She was still totally out but did sit up once head tilted to the left, she looked to me to be in pain. The vet now on duty now suggested the discussion of quality of life. Which I determined to be siding on euthanasia. They did say we could go through an MRI but she would had to be fully sedated. We had our concerns about sedation because she had a heart issue. My vet would not put her under to clean her teeth because of a concern she could pass. She also suffered from arthritis likely hip dysplasia (hard time sitting down and getting up) and an eye issue (eyelid tumor and degenerative eye disease). After a discussion with my wife we decided on allowing her to pass because of keeping her around was more for us. Not for her.
Doing research I now think she had a vestibular issue like an inner ear infection. Could have also been a tumor. I wish the emergency room vets would have given us more of a ray of hope. I know now, like they did say, it would have been a long road ahead but we have been there before with other issues she had. I wish I had asked more questions. I suffer from guilt every day now. We miss our best friend terribly.
Dear Bill,
My heart aches for you with the loss of your beloved pup. I understand how your mind runs through all the “what ifs” while grieving. But please don’t let guilt weigh heavily on you. From what you describe, this does not sound like a vestibular issue but rather something more serious like a brain tumor. I honestly feel you made the most loving choice by offering your girl peace and freedom from her suffering. I hope with time your heart can begin to heal and the grief will fade. May the memories of all the good times you shared stay with you always. Bless you. ♥
My Schnaupin was 15 years old and I had beliefs that he would have 1 to 2 more years with me. He was licking his tummy area for sometime. The Vet said it was allergies. So I stopped taking him in to care for that. I have learned since that severe licking means they are in pain. I could also tell he had trouble getting his pee pee put in after pooping….probably from pain or cancer. I didn’t have a Vet look at him because of the expense and age. He then had a fatty tissue bump that grew huge and hard on his thigh, we let that go for a while, then had it surgerically removed. It then cause his leg to swell and he had horrible ulcers on his tummy area that started to ooze.
I felt that I put him down too soon. We were scheduled to leave out of country and I knew I couldn’t leave him with someone for that week. I scheduled an at home euthanasia (expensive but worth it for my faithful companion). I felt if this trip could have been at a different time I would have had a few more months with him.
I felt like I betrayed him, watching him go. I have a small garden area with a stone with his name on it.
Then…. we got puppy 2 weeks later! A joy but again, I feel I’ve betrayed my beloved Schnaupin again.
Hi Michele, Reading your story, I don’t think you betrayed your dog at all. If he had swelling and oozing sores, that was definitely uncomfortable for him. I think you made the best decision by letting him go peacefully (I am so happy to hear that you orchestrated it at home) before things got much worse. Bless you. ♥️
This article touched me! We had to put our beloved 17 yo Shit-Tzu to sleep two years ago. I am absolutely haunted and cannot let the guilt go. It was a middle of the night episode of sheer terror she endured that made us take her in. She was blind and had dementia, but still got around ok and ate/drank. I know it was time, but the ER Vet was busy that night and after the exam told us she was stable. We didn’t want her to go through another episode again, especially if we weren’t there for her, so we made the decision to euthanize. With the first shot, she cried out for a while minute!! I was devastated. Of course the sedative finally kicked in, but the fact that she had pain just kills me. I wish we had brought her home and gone to our own vet the next day. I feel like I caused her pain at the very end. She was my baby.
Hello Joan, I’m so sorry to read that you’ve carried this guilt. I know your dog would not want that for you and I really want you to KNOW that you did the best you could with the information you had. You would have felt TERRIBLY if you’d taken her home and she DID have another episode that night. You made the best decision you could for her and I think you chose wisely. Please read this companion article for more information that I think will help you: https://toegrips.com/preparing-for-dog-euthanasia/ I’m not sure the crying out equated to pain, as I describe in this article. I really really hope you find peace in this memory. ♥️ Bless you.
My Schnauzer cried out in pain with the first shot too and then she went right out. I hate that the last thing she felt was pain even though it was only for a second. I had wanted her to go peacefully.
Hi Joan,
thank you for sharing your story.
We also made the difficult decision to say goodbye to our 16.5 y/o Shih Tzu last week and heartbreak is an understatement. He was diagnosed with liver cancer over a year ago but he still managed to live his best life until the very end. We just pray we made the right decision by letting him sleep in peacefully, and that he knows how much he was loved by all of us.
Reading everyone’s stories and knowing that whatever I feel is normal during the grieving process, is comforting and healing.
Two days ago I held my sweet boy Kenji in my arms when he took his last breath. My heart hurts so bad right now and the tears just won’t stop. I’m trying to accept that it was the right decision, but I can’t help but think that’s a lie I’m telling myself to feel better.
He was with me for 16 and a half years. I brought him home as a puppy. He was so healthy for so long but began to decline over the past few years due to canine cognitive dysfunction. He gradually lost his sight and I could no longer take him on walks. He stopped sleeping through the night and became incontinent. His barking became more like howls of pain and anxiety.
I think I was in denial for a long time about how poor his quality of life had become. His condition really caused a lot of strain between my partner and me. I feel horrible now for the times I got frustrated or angry at him. I feel guilty and keep thinking maybe I could have gotten him more help or tried some other medication or spent more time with him at the end.
I know on a rational level that it was time to let him go – probably way past the time – but that doesn’t make the hurt go away. He was a part of my life for so long it feels like a part of me has died too.
Hi Ryan,
My heart goes out to you. I can feel your pain and tell how much you loved Kenji. Losing a dog to canine cognitive dysfunction can be so difficult because while their body may still be somewhat healthy, their mind is not, and they are no longer the same dog. It sounds like you took amazing care of him and made the most loving choice you could—the choice to set him free.
Please don’t be too hard on yourself about the times when you got frustrated or let yourself get stuck in guilt over what could have been. I have no doubt that Kenji knew how much you loved him and that he loved you too. I hope that in time the grief lessens a little and you find a measure of comfort in all the good memories you had with Kenji. Thinking about you!❤️
P.S. My dear friend Dr. Woodruff wrote an amazing article about making the decision to euthanize a dog with dementia. In case it would help you as you process your loss, here is a link to it: Dementia in Dogs: When to Euthanize Your Beloved Senior Dog