
Finding peace in your heart after the goodbye
Grieving the loss of a dog after euthanasia is every shade of difficult. After listening to a dear friend express the guilt she felt following her dog’s euthanasia, integrative veterinarian Dr. Julie Buzby shares a heartfelt message on finding peace after the goodbye.
I learned something this week that broke my heart. My friend Jamie has been living with needless guilt for years over the way her dog was euthanized.
Having been a part of hundreds of dog euthanasias, I’m melted each time by the grief, but I’ve also come to terms with the value of a peaceful, gentle euthanasia. However, it never occurred to me that a client might linger in doubt or guilt about the way their pet was euthanized.
So I think it’s worth having a hard conversation about grieving the loss of a dog after euthanasia. After Jamie and I talked, she sent me the sweetest message:
“Thank you for the kind words. It puts peace in my heart.“
Whether saying goodbye to your dog is a part of your past or your future, I want you to have peace in your heart too.

Two senior dogs and two different goodbyes
So let’s back up to beginning. In the midst of a recent string of texts Jamie and I exchanged about senior dog care, she asked me this question about dog euthanasia:
I had two different experiences with saying goodbye to my two dogs. And I keep questioning which one was right?”
This clearly wasn’t a conversation to be had via text. So I called her and asked for the backstory before I offered my thoughts.
Here is Jamie’s story about grieving the loss of her dogs:
Saying goodbye to Sabrina: Jamie’s story
“When I lost my first dog, Sabrina, it was winter. My parents were snowbirds and living in south Florida. I had planned on driving to stay the holiday with them as Sabrina and I always had.

It turned out to be the longest trip of my life as I stopped at various veterinary hospitals along the way since Sabrina was not breathing well. I finally made it to my destination and for a few days Sabrina perked up. But when we had two nights in a row without sleep due to her labored breathing, no longer wanting to eat nor even sit in the room with our family, I knew it was time.
Related article: Signs Your Dog is Dying
The next morning, I went to a local veterinary office while Sabrina stayed home with my parents. The vet came out and spoke with me, read Sabrina’s records that I’d brought along, and we scheduled her appointment for later that same day.
When the vet met Sabrina, he said she was so calm that only one shot would be needed. He explained that once he gave the injection, it would take no longer than 10 seconds to work.
I looked into Sabrina’s beautiful brown eyes and told her that I loved her and everything I wanted to say. My mom and sister-in-law were at my side also telling her how loved she was. Within what felt like two to three seconds, she dropped into my arms. The vet then listened for a heartbeat and softly told me she was gone. I held her for ten minutes and then my father and brother came in and helped me to the car.
Ruminating over the guilt of my dog’s passing
It was not until years later that I would feel guilt about my decisions and the questions I did not ask.
When I knew my next dog, Rémedy, only had a little time left, I was blessed to be able to take almost two weeks off work to be with her. Rémedy was a blind/deaf dog I had rescued.
Related article: Meet Rémedy—10 Tips for Whole Pet Healthcare
I always sensed Rémedy felt so alive at the ocean. She would put her head up in the breeze and sniff the oceans smells. She even had an extra pep in her step when we would walk along with our feet/paws in the ocean.

So we traveled to Folly Beach. We also went to our favorite spot at the river. We spent time with family. And of course I spoiled her with her favorite treats.

Making arrangements for Rémedy’s goodbye
I had made arrangements with my local vet to say goodbye in a specific way. I told the vet I wanted Rémedy to be on my lap, and I wanted to hold her the whole time. We went in to the room—my mom was at my side. The room was lit softly, and the vet came in and told me there would be two shots. One to relax her and then the final injection. I said ok. But once the first injection was given, her head dropped and she was completely out of it. Not relaxed…gone.
Before the euthanasia injection, the vet asked me, “Are you ready?” Then a second time, “Are you sure you are ready?” even though I had answered yes the first time. I held my girl and told her how I loved her. Then the vet listened for a heartbeat and told me she was gone. I held her for ten minutes and then my parents helped me leave.
I left that experience with a lot of guilt and sadness. The first shot did not just relax her. She was limp.
Grieving the loss of my sweet dog after euthanasia
If I had known she would be that out of it, I would have said the things I wanted to say to her before that first injection. Or maybe I would have requested just one shot, like Sabrina. Or I would have said my last words to her first and then told the vet to immediately give the second shot and not ask me and wait in between.
I’ve often replayed it in my mind.
Since then, I have discussed my experiences with others who are making the difficult decision for their dogs. I’m still left not knowing what is right and what is wrong so that I may be prepared better for the next time.
I do know I should have asked many more questions. For example, does one method cause pain while the other is painless? I don’t know why this question didn’t come to me at the time, but who is thinking clearly when they are about to lose their best friend?”
Dr. Buzby shares a heartfelt message of comfort
As I listened to Jamie share the differences between Rémedy’s and Sabrina’s passing, my heart ached for her. It was clear that her unanswered questions had lingered and guilt had bubbled up over the years causing her unnecessary pain.
However, I also knew that words of reassurance, comfort, and truth could help. Here’s what Jamie needed to know:
There is no “right” way to perform a euthanasia in terms of standard operating procedure. Ultimately, euthanasia is about what is best for the dog. Period.

And after that, it’s about determining the preferences of the dog’s family. Like most of veterinary medicine, helping a dog transition out of this life is more of an art than a science. This is precisely why Jamie had two different experiences, and why she was conflicted.
The guiding principle for end-of-life care
While there is no “right” protocol for dog euthanasia, there is a “right” guiding principle. The “right” way to perform a euthanasia is to make it physically and emotionally pain free for the dog. Dog euthanasia is euphemistically referred to as “putting a dog to sleep” for a reason. That’s the goal.
Sabrina’s vet opted to give her one injection because he believed that, in her debilitated state, she would go right to sleep without any struggle from the euthanasia solution, which essentially induces general anesthesia and then gradually stops the heart.
With Rémedy, the vet opted to “take out an insurance policy” to guarantee a perfect process. Dog euthanasia has to earn a procedural perfect 10 every single time. There is no room for error.
By administering a sedation injection in advance, this vet followed the protocol that the vast majority of vets use today. I almost always administer a sedative injection before the final injection for these reasons:
- any anxiety or pain the dog is feeling melts away under the influence of the medicine
- when the dog relaxes, the owners also tend to visibly relax
- and, if I’m honest, the vet is more relaxed too because a quiet, calm goodbye is almost guaranteed once the dog is sedated.
Facilitating a compassionate goodbye
A euthanasia appointment is such a precious, vulnerable time for the hearts of all present. I’ve obliged all kinds of special requests because there is no “right way.”
My final answer to the question Jamie texted me is this: both vets were right. They both facilitated a compassionate, peaceful goodbye.
Honoring your dog by giving yourself peace
If the guilt of your dog’s goodbye lingers in your heart—whether your dog’s passing was recent or years ago—I hope that by sharing Jamie’s story, you find peace. Ultimately, you were there for your dog in those final moments when he needed you most.
If you’re preparing for your dog’s passing
If your dog’s passing is looming on the horizon, please read part two of this series: Preparing for Your Dog’s Euthanasia: 10 Thoughts for Peace. We’re here to offer comfort and support during this difficult time.
Finally, if you’re navigating your dear old dog’s senior years, I invite you to sign up for my weekly updates, tips, and articles dedicated to senior dog care.


My amazing sweet sweet female German shepherd named Hunter was put down 6 days ago. She was a little over nine, and she came to me when she was two months old. She was a beautiful purebred girl, I raised her for the last nine years in the redwoods of northern California. She was active every single day, roaming the yard, jumping in the ocean, and several rivers. She loves sticks and balls and she protected my three-year-old daughter fiercely. No one could get near our house without her barking, but she was so good with people. She was a happy happy dog, we recently had moved in February around her birthday, which got lost in the stress of moving, and we came back down south to live with my parents. There she got walked every day by my daughter myself, and so on the ball to at the park. But she was not living her fun active lifestyle that she had her whole life. She woke up Sunday and was completely paralyzed, I have been really busy the week before and hadn’t spent a lot of time with her. I threw the ball to her a couple days before she passed, and she tired out faster than normal. Saturday I was out for a friends birthday all day, and when I got home late at night I just crawled into bed and didn’t even check on her. I just thought she was sleeping upstairs like she normally does. I didn’t think anything of it, she’s been limping a little bit that day but she’s lint from time to time. When she woke up on Sunday she was paralyzed and could not even go to the backyard to relieve her self. My dad, Neighbor, and I carried her to the backyard. Our dear family friend who is a retired that came over and checked her out, she said that Hunter had a spinal cord issue and she needed to go to the vet immediately. When we got to the vet I was a mess, she spent a couple hours alone in the back of the vet hospital where the kind woman who put her down did tests. The vet came out and told me Hunter was indeed paralyzed and in an incredible amount of pain. She said that the surgeries we would need to do were not only expensive but inhumane to do to such a large active dog who had lived a full life already. I was there alone for about two hours before I decided with my dad that it was best to put her down. My two best friends came right away and we cried and held hunter in the nice little room they do the euthanasia in. She had to be rolled in on a gurney and was sedated and panting heavily and seemed a little distressed. I cried and held her and called my mother who is also one of my closest friends and my mom said I should not be there for the last moments. I was such a mess I could not breathe. I told Hunter I loved her and walked out of the room and my friend stayed with her as she was put down. It seems so mean and cruel and cold I walked away for her last moments and on top of losing my child I literally feel so bad I could not be there in the last minute. But Claire said they sedated her first and she fell asleep then they did the shot, and it was quick and easy. Our family friend told me I did the kind thing for her, because there was absolutely no guarantee should ever walk again, and we would have to use a sling and express her bladder for her for the rest of her life, and even if it was just a few months, my dog would not have wanted to live like that. My biggest regret is that I wasn’t there for the last second but I know that it would’ve messed me up more than it already is messing me up. And she was with my best friend and it was really quick. They didn’t do all the tests to find out why she was paralyzed but it could have been a tumor, degenerative mylopethy, or a slipped disc and two of the three there is nothing you can do really and if it was a slipped disc it would be painful and brutal and there was no guarantee she would walk again.
I mostly just want my heart and brain to be at rest, my daughter who was absolutely in love with my dog, didn’t get to be there for the last year of income at the good thing, but really I wish that more people had been able to come. I will spread some of her ashes in the rivers in Northern California when I get them back. I’ll keep the rest. Am I a horrible person for having to leave the room? I was basically with her till her last moments, maybe just a minute or two before the end. And on the other side of the wall for the very end, weeping like no other.
Dear Anna,
My heart aches for you with your loss of Hunter. I am so sorry she endured such a tragic injury and left you with having to say goodbye. You are not a terrible person for needed to leave the room. Each person is different and what works for one may not work for another. If being present for Hunter’s final moments would have left you with horrible memories and emotions that were too strong, I would have told you it was best to step out. Not only for your sake but so your sweet girl didn’t feed off of your stress and become agitated herself. I am certain she knew how much you loved her and that your friend’s presence was a comfort. May her memory stay with you always and continue to be a blessing to you and your family. Wishing you healing and peace.
I’m so impacted by all of these stories of people and their puppies leaving this world. Our furry friends are so important. My Aussie was put to sleep today – I drove 7 hours back home to my mom and stepdad to be with her when she passed. We got her when I was seven (I’m 21 now). She just turned 14. She was really my mom’s dog, even though we never really said it. Any time my mom got up to do ANYTHING, Basil (my Aussie), would get up and follow her – wherever she went. She was so loyal. Which is why I think that even though she was in pain, because of cancer, (that we couldn’t get out because she had it already before, and was too old to get operated on again) she didn’t wanna leave my moms side. God I love(d) her so much. It hurts so bad.
Two vets came to our home and did it in our living room. We had the fire going, and Basil laid on her bed. My mom and I laid beside her after the sedative while it kicked in, whispering our love to her. My mom kept saying to her “wherever you’re going, I’m going.” I could cry just thinking about it. What a powerful sentence. It was crazy how fast the sedative kicked in, and for a moment, I think my mom and I felt relief that she was calm. She seemed at peace. The second the vet told us she was gone I couldn’t stop sobbing. How could our little Basil, who was just pacing back and forth in the kitchen, not be in her body anymore? Where did she go, if her body is still here? How the fuck does this make sense?
I know I’m being negative and I know we must continue living but I don’t know how to move forward after witnessing her death. Dogs are there for everything.
And now she can’t be here for anything.
How the hell do you process this grief? How do I get over the guilt running through my head that I should’ve walked her more, let her kiss me more often…I feel wrought with anxiety. She was just here and now shes not.
Dear Cammie,
My heart aches for you with your loss of Basil. It is obvious she was a big part of your life and dearly loved by the whole family. You are right that the grief is overwhelming and seems unfair and pointless. But I assure you the pain wouldn’t be possible without the kind of love that swallows you whole and consumes you completely. I can’t imagine living life without having experienced that kind of love. The curse is worth the blessing. You gave your sweet girl a peaceful passing and I’m sure your presence was a comfort. I wish you brighter days ahead and hope that with time the grief will begin to fade. May her memory stay with you always and continue to bring you joy. ♥
I lost my dog in 2021 to euthanasia as she had an ongoing problem that was no longer able to be managed, and just 6 weeks later I lost my partner who I found one early morning, dead to suicide after a life together of 30 years. I moved house (as encouraged by both my doctor and a therapist) and after about 6 months – with everyone’s encouragement again, I obtained a little kitten. However, each time he went to the toilet and meowed, I kept thinking that he was dying and so I had to return him after 3 weeks.
The death of both my dog and my partner so close has made it extremely difficult for me as they were my family and I cannot now separate the two events either in my mind or in my heart. A part of me would like to obtain a part but the other half screams a resounding NO.
It is a difficult feeling to have to contend with. Both deaths have really shattered my life in a lot of ways especially in my confidence and in terms of no longer being able to trust the world as I once knew it. A huge part of this trust relates to obtaining a pet that I can love but yet I feel that I could not go through another death. Deep down I fear that I will never get over losing my desire for another pet (another little dog) but likewise losing the fear of losing that pet.
Logically, I know that everything dies and that loss is a part of life, but Grief is about emotions, not logic. People deliver up their logical platitudes and suggestions, but very few really listen to what I feel and so I more often than not just keep these feelings and thoughts to myself.
At this stage, I see a therapist for Complicated Grief and PTSD, but I cannot share any issues surrounding the death of my dog (or maybe even do not want to). Photos of her and my partner are kept in an album in my bedroom wardrobe for to look upon them just adds to my sadness.
Dear Lawrence,
Your words have touched my heart, and I am truly sorry for all the loss you have endured. I can only imagine how difficult it is to push through each new day with this heavy burden of grief you carry. I completely understand why you are hesitant to bring another pup into your home. That is a very big step and there is no time limit on when (or if) this should be done. If you want to enjoy the company of a dog but are not emotionally ready for a lifetime commitment, there are options you can explore. My local shelter has people volunteer to take dogs walking/hiking and just allow them to get out of the shelter for the day/afternoon. You may find that offering joy for a day to a lonely pup would also bring a bit of happiness to your heart. Don’t push yourself to do anything that is more than what your heart can take, especially just because your grieving process isn’t matching others’ expectations. I know you mentioned you are seeing a therapist, but do you have a good support system in place? If not, I would encourage you to look into a bereavement support group (either online or in person). No one should have to navigate this emotional path alone. Thank you for being willing to reach out and share your story. We are here for you. ♥ Praying for strength and comfort. Bless you.
This Monday we had to make a tough decision we had to put our dog down he was 14 years old 😪. It happened so fast and I never seen him in that condition 💔. He started falling, bumping his head everywhere and the crying it was painful to hear he couldn’t even stand up. we knew something was wrong we rushed him to the hospital and they told us there was nothing they can do and it’s best to put him to sleep. My heart breaks knowing that he is gone especially for my parents my dad is taking it hard he cries , there was a routine when my dog was alive he would go do but now he realizes he isn’t there hurts him. it really sucks this happened and we are going to miss him. today I had to call to reschedule an appointment because I’m mentally not there to go anywhere i started crying i felt embarrassed. My uncle being in the hospital the same day we had to put our dog down its so much going on this week.
Dear Stephanie,
My heart goes out to you with the recent loss of your senior pup. I can only imagine how much you miss him but know you did the only thing you could to offer him peace and freedom from suffering. I hope with time your grief will fade and your heart will begin to heal. May the memories of all the good times you shared be a source of comfort and joy. Bless you and your family. ♥
I’m definitely struggling with having to make the decision to euthanize our sweet boy, Maverik, a 7 year old golden retriever. One week ago he was his usual fun happy go lucky dog and today we are grieving him. Last Sunday we noticed a little difference in his breathing but no other symptoms. Still playing eating going out, than he became a little lethargic so I took him into the vet. The vet said his lungs sound clear and ruled out heartworm and sent us home with an antibiotic and decongestant with the diagnosis of an upper respiratory infection. Within 2 days he took a drastic decline and his breathing became heavy and I rushed him to the emergency vet on Saturday night. They did chest X-rays and immediately put him on oxygen treatment. He’s lungs were filled from fungal pneumonia and kept overnight. The next morning I called for an update and they said he declined and will need to be transported to another hospital with ventilator and his chance of survival was very low and he may not even make the transfer or get to the point of the long road of recovery. I feel like my heart has been ripped out. Our poor baby laid lifeless in his oxygen box with no improvement and every breath was hard for him. After telling our kids 20 & 22 we need to make a decision and the vets at both clinics agree it’s best to put him out of his suffering.
I’m consumed with guilt, what if I got him to another vet a day sooner? Could he recover with more oxygen treatment? So many what ifs… in the end we let him go and it has been the worst 3 days of my life.
Our family dog, our youngest member of the family that we all picked out together is gone at only 7. I’m heartbroken and devastated and can’t help but feel guilty.
Dear Jill,
My heart aches for you with your loss of Maverik. I can only imagine how much you miss him but am certain he knew how much he was loved. You made a selfless choice to allow your own heart to break so your sweet boy wouldn’t have to suffer needlessly. There is no greater gift we can offer a beloved pup than a peaceful goodbye. I hope with time your heart will begin to heal. May Maverik’s memory stay with you and always be a blessing in your life. Wishing you and your family brighter days ahead as you continue life’s journey. ♥
please help me, I am absolutely devastated and cant move on. On 30th November 2023, I euthanised my 2 furbabies. Sally and Ty were chihuahua crosses, they were 15 yo bonded brother and sister. on 30th September we rushed Ty to vet with difficulty breathing and he was diagnosed with an enlarged heart and was in congestive heart failure. He pulled through and was put on pimoden and furosimide only a low dose, we were told he had 6 to 12mths. in October Sally had blood tests done and the vet said all her kidney/liver test results were really bad but never offered any options to us like meds etc so we thought she was okay. her only symptoms were increased thirst and urination. Ty had a few ups and downs and I had been talking to a lovely vet that did home euthanasia and we had decided they would both go together given thier age, health and bonding. The morning of the 30th Ty was struggling to breath again, not as bad as the 1st time but we took him to the vet and she gave him another fluid injection and left the decision up to us. I was so upset I couldn’t decide so my Husband made the decision. I contacted the lady and she wasn’t available and the vet said she could come to our house and do them and we were so relieved as we didn’t want to do it at the vet because they hated it there. when the vet came to the house an hour later Sally was so defensive barking and trying to protect us and Ty. when the vet gave her the sedative in her leg she just screamed and screamed and held her leg up, the vet then did Ty and he was just yelping and yelping. It absolutely broke our hearts that we did that to them in thier own home, the place they always felt safe. The sedative knocked Sally out in under 5 mins. she was completely unconscious with her tongue hanging out of her mouth, I never had a chance to talk to her and soothe her. I feel so guilty for doing that to them when they trusted me. I wish I had of said no, I want to try more meds for Ty 1st. They still had good quality of life, they were eating well even Ty that morning still had his breakfast and was walking around outside enjoying the morning even though he was struggling to breathe. they both had good hearing, eyesight and teeth. coats were thick and glossy.. I will never forgive myself, I think I did it way to soon and I will never forgive myself for bringing them pain in their own home where they always felt secure. i have there medical notes and sometimes think of seeing another vet to just reassure me, i did the right thing. My marriage is now suffering as I cannot handle the greif and I can feel myself distancing myself from my Husband. I will never get over what I did to my poor little babies that trusted me.
Dear Joanne,
My heart aches for you as you grieve the losses of your beloved pups. I am sorry the euthanasia process was not what you expected and has left you with negative feelings surrounding those last moments with your senior dogs. You did what you thought was best and gave your dogs peace and rest the only way you could. If your girl was experiencing end stage liver and kidney failure and your boy was struggling to breathe, then I do think you made the most loving decision for them. I hope with time the grief will fade and you can begin to find some happiness in your days. Please don’t try to walk this path alone. Reach out for help to a friend or even to a therapist or counselor. It is ok to get support from others and completely normal to need a shoulder to lean on when working your way through such strong emotions. Here is a link to the Humane Society’s website that contains several links to pet bereavement support groups: https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/how-cope-death-your-pet
May Sally and Ty’s memories stay with you always and be a source of comfort as you continue life’s journey. Praying for healing for your heart and your marriage. ♥
My gorgeous 4 year old bulldog as just been put to sleep, I took him to emergency vets he had been vomiting few days before but stopped and back to his usual cheeky self! Then he started again, drinking a lot and struggling to pee this came on so suddenly I got him in emergency vets Sunday, they said he had about 12 kidney stones, they put him under anaesthetic tried to cathriter etc and I was called to say it was kindest to put him to sleep whilst under as there was nothing they could do! I feel so guilty how did I not know he had kidney stones, he was only 4! I feel horrible I didn’t even get to say bye! I loved him like a kid, my other boy shandy staffy passed age 14 in his sleep next to me, I still miss him but Reggie was only 4 I feel like it’s my fault, I can’t eat or sleep! Feel like the worst person! How did I not know he had kidney stones till it was too late! Sounds dramatic but don’t think I can forgive myself!
Dear Stacey,
My heart aches for you with the tragic loss of your beloved Reggie. You didn’t do anything wrong and there were probably no early warning signs to miss. I know you would have done anything to give your boy more time, but you made the most loving choice to free him from his suffering. I hope you can allow yourself some grace and leave behind the unnecessary burden of guilt you are carrying. May Reggie’s memory be with you always and bring your heart happiness and joy. Bless you. ♥
It has been a month since I lost my baby boy to Dementia. My pup was 16, I am so tortured if I did the right thing for him. I am haunted that if I had just taken him to the Vet one last time to be sure, I would not be feeling like I do, ridden with guilt that the decision, made by my husband was the wrong one and I was the one who acted on it, because even though he made the decision, I had to take my baby boy and be the one to hold him while he took his last breath. and my husband could not. Maxx wore a diaper, he had lost his potty training ability and would potty in the house after going out, I cleaned it up, I did that with no problem, he was also deaf, it took him a long time to eat, and he would cock his head like it was hard for him to chew at times, at 16 his dental health was not good. We had to medicate him with xanax to help with the constant pacing. When he went out, he would have to be helped out of the door, he would fall while running in the grass, The day our beloved pup passed, he was running in the yard, back and forth, without purpose, he was doing that when we took him out just run back and forth. He would not potty, maybe pee, but then when we brought him back in he would poop in the house and then walk through it. He wore a diaper because he peed on the floor. I did not mind, and cleaned up the mess no matter what. Our dog that day experienced some pain in his hip, I don’t know why, maybe while running that morning, but my husband made the decision to let him go. I looked for Vets that would come to the house, but it was the day before New Years Eve and everyone was on holiday. I finally got hold of a doctor who told me to give him a Tramadol for pain, and our dog laid down and slept. When he got up he tried to walk over to his food bowl and sprawled on all fours in front of it. I picked him up and took him to the ER clinic. As they took my baby boy to the back to put in the cath, he looked at me with those eyes and it haunts me, what was he saying to me, I can’t stop seeing his face constantly, feeling his body in my arms, so warm, trusting me. I wish I had run out of the ER clinic and waited until I saw our vet one last time and was sure I was doing the right thing. I feel like I did not have the time to make sure, I was rushed, I did not make sure it was time. It was not my decision, it was my husbands, but when it came to it, I was the one who had to take our dog, he could not. I am angry, hurt, guilty, in so much pain, I cry all the time, I can’t get this out of my mind, it’s all I think about and I just can’t get past this horrible guilt that I should have waited. a few day’s. With the dementia, we had decided to give it a month to see if we could see a response to the medication we were trying. Selgline, and some weight gain medication, We did not keep that promise to ourselves. Maxx had gone from 10 lbs to 8 He had been to the Vet a few weeks prior because he had a panic while we were away and clawed at the door and tore his nails and bled all over the house. The vet said his hind was weak, and he had lost weight, but otherwise, he was healthy. Maxx was deaf, for the past 6 months. It took him hours to eat, he would take a bite, and drop it all over away from his bowl, then scatter more and eventually eat it, sometimes he would take his vitamin in his mouth and hold it, not knowing what to do with it, so I know he was so confused, but was confusion a reason to euthanize him? NO. I don’t know how to get over this, I am making myself sick, I know, but don’t know how to stop this pain. and guilt. Why didn’t I wait to make sure, would it have made a difference? I will never know. all I know right now is I can’t stop seeing his face looking back at me. I think I am having an abnormal response to this, can you give me some insight? We are going to get a new dog to try to fill this hole, our house is too quiet, we need a dog to love, I hope this helps us.
Dear MD,
My heart aches for you with your recent loss of Maxx. Saying goodbye to a beloved dog is always hard but I do think you made the right choice. It is ok to let go while there is still some joy left, before all happiness is lost and the only thing that remains is pain and struggling. We as humans tend to look to the future and anticipate the good that could come. Dogs are not this way. They live only for today. So, if all today brings is anxiety, confusion, restlessness, fear, and pain, then I do not think that is the quality of life they deserve. The tragic truth of dementia is all the disease is mental and physically they do seem to be fairly healthy. But I am convinced that mental disease causes just as much suffering (if not more) than physical disease. I always think it is better to say goodbye one day too early rather than one day too late and allow unnecessary suffering. I cannot think of a more selfless act of love than to allow your own heart to break so Maxx could find peace and rest. I hope with time you will allow yourself some grace and your heart will begin to heal. May Maxx’s memory be with you always and remain a blessing in your life. ♥
My 8.5 yr old boxer buddy died 6 days ago and I too am devastated. I had taken him to the vet as he was breathing rapidly, panting, swollen, and had a big mass on his head that we were trying to resolve w prednisone at high doses. My guilt sits w the prednisone and whether it was helping or hurting, but it was so much more and probably cancer.. The vet warned that if I took him home he might well pass that night, and he recommended taking him to the ER. We did that. It was the worst moment of the day as he too stared at me as they gurney’d him to the back and I didn’t even say goodbye. When they handed me an estimate with a $10k down payment for a night of testing (not fixing because that would come after extensive testing and another estimate), I knew he wouldn’t live through a scary night of prodding. I wanted him back and immediately shut down the fast moving ER train. They get you bc you are panicking and grieving. It was sickening. We got him back after 20 minutes and an attempt to wrangle &800 from us for office visit and prep for a catheter that wasn’t approved yet bc the estimate wasn’t approved, and we got out as fast as we could. . I slept next to my dog on the floor that night, telling him how loved he was by the family and my friends and saying the Lord’s Prayer over and over to him. . I fell asleep and when I woke up in the morning he had passed away. I hadn’t heard anything. I sat with him and petted him for 5 hours until my son came to help me, and we buried him in a beautiful sunny spot in the yard he loves. It’s been 6 days and I am a wreck. Your story helped me bc I know I need another baby to complete my home which now feels cold and quiet, and that’s ok. Joaquin was my 4th dog and my best buddy. I will miss him forever. Know there is no perfect death of our doggo’s, and that they know for sure how loved they have been and how much love they have given.
Dear Penny,
I am so sorry for your loss of Joaquin. What a blessing he was at home and passed peacefully next to you as he slept. I can only imagine how much you miss him and understand wanting to bring another pup into your home for love and comfort. Wishing you brighter days ahead and praying for healing for your heart. ♥
We rescued an abused, anxiety, dog from a dog fighting ring. It took three years for him to become a dog! He came with many emotional and health problems like heart worm and hook worm. After he was cleared of heart worm, he had his spleen removed due to a massive tumor in September. He seemed to be doing well. Except lately he seemed to have slowed down (he was 9 years old). He peed in the house a few days ago and didn’t seem to know it. He yell when my husband moved him even though it was gently. His walks he started to slow down. He was a tough resilient dog. Yesterday he collapsed and when I took him to emergency his blood was low and severely anemic. I was in total shock as the day before he was so active. The cost was over $5,000 just to hospitalize him and blood transfusions until they could figure out what was happening.. They suspected cancer or kidneys or possibly infections. unfortunately I could not afford it as I was still paying for his last surgery and his behavioral meds and such were depleting my savings. I made the choice to euthanize which was so difficult. He was struggling to walk and very weak and even if we did blood transfusions not guaranteed it wouldn’t happen again. I suspect he had cancer. I know gave him the best three years and did everything to help him with his issues. He had behavioral vet and training. Special food ( the dog fight people had removed his teeth) He was such a good dog. I feel awful and guilty. I have other dogs but this one was special.
Dear Lisa,
My heart goes out to you with the recent loss of your beloved pup. He sounds like a once in a lifetime kind of guy and he was so lucky to have found you when he did. I know it was hard to choose to say goodbye, but I am certain it was the most loving option. Thank you for giving him a second chance at life and offering him the happiness he deserved. May his memory stay with you always and be a blessing in your life. ♥
I had to euthanize our 15 year old pug a few days ago. She was the sweetest thing to me. She would aways be so excited when I would walk in the door, she traveled with us, slept with us, cuddled on the couch. 3 years ago we had our first child and our poor pug, Cricket, took a backseat. i
I did my best to spend as much time with her and make her feel loved but it never was like it used to be. Within the past year or so she began to show some signs of dementia. She would seem lost, had some accidents in the house etc. Her hind quarters began to deteriorate and she began having bowel accidents. Late Sept we had our second child. Poor cricket really took the backseat when she needed me the most. I still cared for her the best I could. I had a full body harness to help her walk outside and I held her up the eat. She wore diapers and still had accidents. I took leave from work to help out with the kids and Cricket and I watched her continue to deteriorate. She would pant more in bed, she was pretty much in her bed because she could barely use her hind legs, she would whimper and cry unless I was right there with her. I got so aggravated at times because of all the stress with a post partum wife, a newborn, a 3 year old and Cricket. We put her to sleep on the 16th of Sept at home. I have such gut wrenching guilt about it. I wish I could have made her last few days, weeks, months better. I would actually think how much easier things will be without having to care for her. I would take her out in the middle of the night so she could go potty and eat and maybe get some more sleep. I hated it, but now I miss it so much. I still wake and look for her at the foot of the bed and she’s not there. I still tell her I’ll be right with her after I finish with kids and I’ll take her out. She would get so anxious about the vet and I always told her it would be OK, but this last time I think she knew that it was the end. I laid with her on the floor and had my hand on her through the process, but now I wish I held her. I miss her so much, I look for her in her spots, I still keep my legs curled in bed so as not to kick her in my sleep. I feel drawn to the spot in the living room where she breathed last. I had a major anxiety attack todaythinking about what I did. How could I have ended her life, she was so in love with me and I was the only one who cared for her at the end. I know her quality of life was not great and was not dignified being bed ridden and wearing diapers, being held to eat, but she still loved me and wanted me to save her up to the end. The guilt is tearing me up but I’m trying to stay as strong as I can for my family. I miss her so much.
Hi Doug,
My heart breaks for you on the loss of Cricket and for all the guilt and pain you are feeling. It is clear from your post that you loved her deeply and took wonderful care of her. Caring for a dog with mobility issues, dementia, and incontinence is challenging on its own, and then adding in two young kids and all the changes that parenthood brings would make it even more difficult. You are not alone in feeling the way you did, and still do. Caregiver fatigue is common in dog parents who are caring for an aging or sick dog (so much so that I’m about to write an article on it). You did not fail her in any way, or give up on her. Instead, you cared for her to the best of your abilities, and then you made the merciful decision to set her free from her frail body and failing mind. It was the right thing to do, and the most loving choice you could make.
I hope that in time the guilt and sorrow you are facing will decrease and you will be able to see what a wonderful life Cricket had with you and how lucky she was to have been loved by you. ❤️
Hi Doug. I read your words, and they resonated with me so much. I’m sorry you’re feeling the way that you’re feeling, but I can assure you that I understand. I had to say my last goodbye to my senior dog Lucy less than one week ago. Everything that you’ve described about Cricket is almost identical to the things that I am feeling and have experienced. I do not yet have children, however, I am expecting my first child in about 12 weeks. It has been such a challenge since I became pregnant and I was the sole provider for her and my future daughter. Lucy struggled with dementia, as well as arthritis and varying other health issues, related to her ability to eat, and do basic things around the house and on her own accord. Many times when I went to go out to walk my younger dog, Lucy would be fast asleep, and other times she would randomly pop up out of bed and try to follow us to the door to come along. Still breaks my heart to see her standing there and confused as to why she couldn’t go, but she really couldn’t walk that far, maybe not more than half a block. She often got lost and disoriented in the yard, standing there as though she didn’t understand why she was outside. It broke my heart.
Please know that you’re not alone. I’ve cried and cried and beat myself up over my lack of patience, and the stress I felt and frustration over the past several months. I wish I could’ve done better to care for her, and to have the ability to have more easily taken her with me everywhere. The sad truth is that she even became fearful in the car for the last several months before her passing. A dog that once loved to go for rides, now panted repeatedly, and appeared to be extremely anxious, even just to drive across town.
I appreciate you sharing your story. It makes me feel better to know that I’m not the only one who lives with regrets about all of this. I hope it brings you some sense of comfort too. I believe that time is the healer of many things and I believe that’s what it will take for both of us. I also tend to believe that there is a very special place for animals to go after they’ve physically gone from this earth. Thinking of you and sending love and light.
Dear Cassaundra,
My heart goes out to you with your recent loss of Lucy. Thank you for being willing to offer sympathy and comfort to others while you work through your own grief and heartache. May your sweet girl’s memory be a source of joy in your life and stay with you always. Wishing you peace and happier days ahead as you continue life’s journey. Congratulations on the impending arrival of your new baby. Bless you both. ♥
When I read your story, it was like you were telling “my” story. Exactly. Yesterday, 12/27 23, I had my sweet sweet miniature schnauzer down. Her name was Tessa, and she was 15.5 yo. I had her since she was 8 weeks old. I know it’s still early, but my heart is broken. Sounds absolutely crazy, but all I want is to hold her. I want her back. You see, I’m a divorced senior, and it was just me and her. She was my everything. I’m actually ashamed for people to see how much I am grieving. I can’t eat, can’t sleep, I smell her bed, her pillows, her blankets… trying to just smell her. I feel lost, and I don’t know what to do.
Dear Sabrina,
My heart aches for you as you grieve the loss of your beloved Tessa. I can only imagine how much you miss her. I hope with time your heart will begin to heal and you can focus on the wonderful life you shared. Here is a link to another article that will help with ideas on how to honor the legacy your sweet girl left behind: Dog Memorial Ideas: 10 Ways to Honor Your Dog’s Legacy
May her memory stay with you always and be a blessing to you. ♥
I understand I lost my fur boy a month ago,I cry I hVe his blanket I sleep with everynight..I had him put down,he couldn’t eat drink,I had to use a syringe and he couldn’t move no legs at all.i turned him ,he pee on himself I cleaned him .put pads under him.i even given hi. enemas.i feel after his second seizure this one really hurt hi.
in a week I took him to vet 5 times,she said I needed to put him down..
at the time I said I got to try to help him.finally I did and regret it like ever! I cry much! maybe he would hD gotten better.he trusted me.im broken badly
Dear Nancy,
I am so sorry for the loss of your beloved pup. You made the loving choice to give him peace and rest the only way you could. I can only imagine how much you miss him but hope you will find comfort in knowing that he lived a happy life with you. Praying for your comfort and healing. Bless you. ♥
I just put my 13 year old yorkie down 2 days ago. I, too, feel such horrible guilt about the last year or two of her life. I got her in college, she was my best girl through everything… school, moving, starting my career, getting married, and all four of my kids. We got a Frenchie a year and a half ago and Roxy was not a fan. Finally the French started leaving her alone but not a before a situation where our French bulldozed her and hurt her. Then, I had my last child 7 months ago. Roxy started going down really about a year ago and I knew it but I was just so busy with my children and my work that I couldn’t devote the time to her that she deserved. I feel like such a jerk. She followed me everywhere, slept with me every night, and was on my lap every time I sat down. I just wish I had spent more time loving on her the last year of her life. Holding her and looking her in her eyes in the euthanasia room it just felt like too little too late. It’s just so hard when they’ve been such a constant in your life for so many years.
Dear Adrienne,
My heart aches for you with your loss of Roxy. It is easy to get caught up in all the “what ifs” but I am certain your girl lived a great life and knew how much you loved her. I hope with time your grief will fade and you can take comfort in knowing she was happy by your side. May her memory always be a blessing in your life. Wishing you all the best as you and your family continue life’s journey.
We had to euthanize out 12.5 year old Golden Retriever, named Leo this past Wednesday. I’m eating myself alive with guilt wondering if I did the right thing so sudden. I think what makes it even worse is he was still wagging his tail & so happy to see us before he was euthanized. He got a good bill of health in Feb of this year. Just arthritis in his hind end & they mentioned possible Lar Par due to a raspy bark ( but couldn’t diagnose without official tests). I never got a chance to do that due to 2 deaths in the family then my dad sick/hospitalized in July & August. I dropped him off Wednesday at 10:30am for the vet to see what might have been going on. In the past 2 weeks he was having episodes of coughing, regurgitating food/water, & alot more hind end weakness. The vet called me 5hrs later, to say I had one sick pup ☹️ She said Leo had megaesophagus, myasthenia gravis & a bad case of aspiration pneumonia. Also he lost weight since his visit in Feb. I knew he was getting older & was sick but I never realized it was that bad. It seemed to happen so fast. She recommended Leo going to the ER vet to stay overnight to continue his antibiotics, but mentioned even if he made it out of the pneumonia, his prognosis still wasn’t good & said euthanasia was also an option. During the month of August I could see his quality of life diminish but he still had good days so I held on to hope during those days selfishly. We made the decision to euthanize him. We didn’t want to see him suffer & was afraid if he did get pneumonia again it could be worse. Plus unfortunately financial wise it would be hard. We brought his bed into the vets office with his favorite toy-Lamb chop. The vet techs gave him all kinds of goodies to eat. Our 3 kids came to say goodbye while my husband & I stayed with him. I laid alongside of him holding his head against mine telling him how much I loved him & would see him on the other side one day. When the vet administered the propofol he let out a little sigh & relaxed. His head fell into my arms. She then administered the next dose to put him to sleep & I lost it. He went so quick. My boy was by my side through everything since he was 10 weeks old. He helped me through my depression & was by my side during my surgeries. After all of it, I just feel like I should have fought more for him to get better, specially since he was still wagging that tail when he seen us all😭
Dear Ashley,
My heart aches for you with your loss of Leo. I can only imagine how much you miss him and understand how emotional it is to choose to say goodbye to a beloved pup. You did the only thing you could to spare him from unnecessary suffering. Offering him peace and rest was the ultimate act of selfless love. I hope with time the grief will fade and you will take comfort in knowing he lived a full and happy life. May his memory stay with you always and continue to be a blessing to you and your family.